When buyers look at where to plant roots around College Station, two neighborhoods that consistently come up are Pebble Creek and Castlegate. While both offer quality living and strong community appeal, the markets are moving differently as we head into 2026. Below, we break down key differences in prices, selling pace, buyer types, and what local agents are seeing in demand.
Price Comparisons
Pebble Creek
-
As of late 2025, the median sale price in Pebble Creek sits around the mid-$600,000s — close to ~$686,000 — and has shown year-over-year growth of about +12%. Redfin
-
Homes in this neighborhood can range from roughly $430K up to $1M+ depending on size, finishes, and lot location. Homes.com
Castlegate
-
By comparison, Castlegate’s median price has been lower, around the low-to-mid $400,000s in recent reports. Redfin
-
This pricing difference positions Castlegate as the more affordable option for buyers who want neighborhood living without Pebble Creek’s premium.
👉 What this means: Buyers looking for larger homes, golf course frontage, or higher-end finishes may lean toward Pebble Creek — while value-oriented buyers often find Castlegate attractive.
Days on Market: How Fast Homes Sell
Pebble Creek
-
Homes in Pebble Creek are moving faster — with median days on market closer to the low teens to mid-50s range, depending on data source. Redfin+1
-
This generally indicates a strong demand relative to supply.
Castlegate
-
Castlegate listings are staying on the market longer — recent data shows a median of about 80–90+ days on market. Redfin
👉 What this suggests: Pebble Creek continues to draw quicker buyer action, while Castlegate sees a more measured sales pace, giving buyers more time to compare.
Who’s Buying Here? (Investor, Families, Downsizers)
Pebble Creek Buyers
-
Primary groups: Established families, move-up buyers, and those seeking spacious homes with good architectural variety. Homes.com
-
With larger lot sizes and a range of home styles, Pebble Creek appeals to buyers who want long-term stability and space for growing households.
Castlegate Buyers
-
Primary groups: First-time buyers, young families, and budget-conscious homeowners.
-
Because Castlegate is more affordable and centrally located near amenities, it attracts buyers who want neighborhood living without a premium price tag.
👉 Expert Insight: Pebble Creek’s diversity of home sizes — from traditional to estate-style — gives it broad appeal, while Castlegate’s value proposition resonates with buyers who prioritize affordability and convenience.
Real Agent Insight on Demand (Local Perspective)
“Pebble Creek remains one of the most desirable neighborhoods because it balances elegance with variety — there’s something for everyone from well-built single family homes to estate properties. The pace is high when the price aligns with buyer expectations, which is why you’ll often see quicker movement here.”
— Local REALTOR®, South Central Texas
“Castlegate performs well for buyers who want neighborhood living at a more accessible price. You won’t see the same rapid absorption as some higher-end areas, but there’s steady interest from families and first-timers who know this is a great place to build equity.”
— Local REALTOR®
Current trends we’re seeing in 2026:
-
Pebble Creek continues to hold ground as a value-plus neighborhood with demand outpacing inventory in key price bands.
-
Castlegate attracts buyers who prefer practical pricing and convenience — and while it doesn’t move as quickly as Pebble Creek, it consistently remains one of the core options for College Station buyers.
Quick Comparison Snapshot
| Metric | Pebble Creek | Castlegate |
|---|---|---|
| Median Home Price (late 2025) | ~$685K+ Redfin | ~$415K+ Redfin |
| Days on Market | ~13–50+ (faster selling) Redfin+1 | ~80–90+ (slower selling) Redfin |
| Typical Buyers | Families, move-ups, long-term owners | First-time buyers, value buyers |
| Market Momentum | Strong & competitive | Steady, measured |
Bottom Line for Buyers in 2026
If you’re shopping for high demand and quicker sales, Pebble Creek tends to lead the way — especially for buyers who value space and long-term lifestyle appeal.
If you’re focused on affordability and neighborhood accessibility, Castlegate offers a compelling entry point where buyers can still build equity without stretching to premium pricing.
